Tenant Advisory Group logoTenant Advisory Group

Sale-Leaseback Resource Center

Sale-Leaseback Accounting Under ASC 842

What a CFO or controller should understand about US GAAP before the letter of intent is signed, because deal terms decide the accounting.

A warehouse building and lift bridge on the Chicago River

By Tenant Advisory Group · Updated

Reviewed by Bill Himmelstein, CNE, Founder, CEO & Managing Broker · Illinois Managing Broker License #471003992 · 26 years in commercial real estate · Last reviewed

Short answer

Under US GAAP (ASC 842-40), the seller-lessee first determines whether the transfer qualifies as a sale. If it does, the company removes the building from its books, recognizes the gain or loss, and records a right-of-use asset and a lease liability for the leaseback. If it does not, the building stays on the books and the cash received is recorded as a financial liability.

The question that comes first: is it a sale?

This guide is for companies that report under US GAAP. It is a plain-language map of the rules, not accounting advice, and your own CPA and auditors should reach the conclusion for your transaction.

A sale-leaseback has two halves, a transfer of the asset and a lease back to the seller. ASC 842-40 does not let a company account for the sale half until it has tested whether a sale really occurred. The test borrows from the revenue standard, ASC 606: there must be a contract, and the buyer-lessor must obtain control of the asset. The indicators of control the standard points to are a present right to payment, legal title, physical possession, the significant risks and rewards of ownership, and acceptance of the asset. PwC's leases guide stresses that these are indicators rather than criteria: not every one has to be present, and they are weighed together from the buyer-lessor's side.

The leaseback alone does not prevent the buyer from obtaining control. Two features of the deal can, however, and both are negotiated business terms.

Sale-leaseback accounting under ASC 842 in five steps

The order of the analysis matters, because each step can end it:

  1. Confirm that a contract exists under ASC 606-10-25-1: both parties have approved it and are committed, each party's rights and the payment terms can be identified, the contract has commercial substance, and collection of the price is probable.
  2. Test whether the buyer-lessor obtains control of the building under ASC 606-10-25-30, weighing the indicators above.
  3. Classify the leaseback. If the seller-lessee would classify it as a finance lease, or the buyer-lessor as a sales-type lease, there is no sale.
  4. Look for a repurchase option. On real estate it generally means there is no sale.
  5. Account for the result: a sale with a leaseback, adjusted for any off-market terms, or a failed sale accounted for as a financing under ASC 842-40-25-5.

Two deal terms that can defeat sale accounting

The first is the classification of the leaseback. Under ASC 842-40-25-2, the buyer-lessor is not considered to have obtained control if the leaseback would be classified as a finance lease by the seller-lessee, or a sales-type lease by the buyer-lessor. In practical terms, an operating leaseback can support sale accounting and a finance leaseback cannot. A lease is a finance lease if it meets any one of five criteria:

  • Ownership of the asset transfers to the lessee by the end of the lease.
  • The lessee has a purchase option it is reasonably certain to exercise.
  • The lease term covers a major part of the asset's remaining economic life.
  • The present value of the lease payments, plus any residual value the lessee guarantees, amounts to substantially all of the asset's fair value.
  • The asset is so specialized that the lessor is expected to have no alternative use for it at the end of the term.

Renewal options count toward the lease term when the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise them, so a long base term with attractive renewals can tip a lease into finance classification. Crowe lists the factors management weighs in that judgment: the cost of finding a new lease, relocation costs, how renewal rent is priced, and leasehold improvements that would still have significant value at the end of the stated term. A significant residual value guarantee by the seller-lessee can also affect the control analysis.

The present value test needs two inputs that are easy to underestimate. ASC 842 sets no bright line for "substantially all", but Crowe notes it is commonly interpreted as 90 percent or more of fair value. And the result depends on the discount rate: private companies that elect the risk-free rate practical expedient use a lower rate than an incremental borrowing rate, which makes the 90 percent level easier to reach.

The second is a repurchase option. Under ASC 842-40-25-3, an option for the seller-lessee to buy the asset back precludes sale accounting unless two conditions are both met: the exercise price is the asset's fair value at the time of exercise, and alternative assets that are substantially the same are readily available in the marketplace. Accounting guides note that real estate is treated as unique and does not meet the second condition, so a repurchase option in a real estate sale-leaseback will generally prevent sale accounting.

Lease term, renewal options, purchase options, guarantees and rent level are all negotiated in the letter of intent. Have your CPA review the term sheet before you sign it, not the lease after it is drafted.

If the transfer qualifies as a sale

When the transfer is a sale, the seller-lessee does three things at closing:

  1. Recognizes the transaction price for the sale at the point the buyer-lessor obtains control.
  2. Derecognizes the carrying amount of the building and land.
  3. Accounts for the leaseback under the normal lessee model, which means recording a right-of-use asset and a lease liability.

The difference between the sale proceeds and the carrying amount is a gain or loss. Under US GAAP the seller-lessee recognizes that gain or loss in full at the sale date, subject to the off-market adjustments described below.

The lease liability is measured from the lease payments, and the right-of-use asset is measured the same way as for any other lease. For an operating leaseback, lease expense is then recognized on a straight-line basis over the term, the liability is reduced using the effective interest method, and both the liability and the right-of-use asset reach zero by the end of the term.

This is the point that surprises owners who remember older rules. A sale-leaseback does not make the occupancy obligation disappear from the financial statements. The owned building and any mortgage on it are replaced by cash, a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. Whether that picture is better or worse for your company depends on your facts and on how your lenders read it.

A worked example: one building, sale vs failed sale

The figures below are hypothetical, for illustration only. They are round numbers chosen to make the arithmetic easy to follow, not market data and not a template for your own entries. Assume:

  • A company sells its building for $5,000,000, which is also the building's fair value, and leases it back for 10 years.
  • Rent is $400,000 a year, paid at the end of each year to keep the arithmetic simple.
  • The property's carrying amount on the company's books is $3,000,000, and depreciation runs $100,000 a year.
  • The company's incremental borrowing rate is 6 percent.
  • There is no purchase option or residual value guarantee, the building is not specialized, and 10 years is well short of its remaining economic life.

Classification first. Discounted at 6 percent, ten payments of $400,000 are worth $2,944,035, about 59 percent of the $5,000,000 fair value, well under the 90 percent benchmark. None of the other finance lease criteria is met, so the leaseback is an operating lease and the transfer can be a sale. Now change one term: the company also gets an option to buy the building back during the first five years. That option is a repurchase right on real estate, so the same deal becomes a failed sale.

At closing (hypothetical)
AccountSale with an operating leasebackFailed sale (same deal plus a repurchase option)
CashDebit $5,000,000Debit $5,000,000
Building and landCredit $3,000,000 (removed from the books)No entry; stays at $3,000,000
Gain on saleCredit $2,000,000None
Right-of-use assetDebit $2,944,035None
Lease liabilityCredit $2,944,035None
Financial liabilityNoneCredit $5,000,000
Year one and beyond (hypothetical)
ItemSale with an operating leasebackFailed sale
Expense for the yearOne straight-line lease cost of $400,000Depreciation of $100,000 plus interest of $300,000 (6 percent of $5,000,000)
Liability at year endLease liability of $2,720,677: interest of $176,642 accrues and the $400,000 payment reduces it by $223,358Financial liability of $4,900,000: the $400,000 payment covers $300,000 of interest and $100,000 of principal
The buildingOff the books; the right-of-use asset is reduced each year and reaches zero at the end of the termStill on the books at $2,900,000 after depreciation
If the option expires unexercised after year fiveNot applicableThe liability has fallen to $4,436,291 and the building is carried at $2,500,000. Both are removed, a gain of $1,936,291 is recognized, and lease accounting begins for the remaining five years

Hypothetical, for illustration. The failed-sale column assumes the 6 percent rate needs no adjustment under ASC 842-40-30-6, which holds here because the liability falls every year and stays above the building's carrying amount.

In this example the expense for year one happens to total $400,000 either way. The balance sheet is where the outcomes part: the sale shows a gain, no building and a lease liability of about $2.9 million, while the failed sale shows the building still on the books, no gain and a financial liability of $5.0 million. That second picture is the one lenders and buyers of your company will read, which is why the repurchase option is worth deciding with your CPA before it goes into the letter of intent.

Off-market terms: when price and rent are not at fair value

Sale price and rent are negotiated together, so the accounting rules check whether the deal as a whole is at fair value. The company compares either the sale price with the fair value of the asset, or the present value of the contractual lease payments with the present value of market-rate lease payments, whichever is more readily determinable.

  • If the sale price is below fair value, the shortfall is treated as prepaid rent. It increases the right-of-use asset, and the gain or loss on sale is adjusted accordingly.
  • If the sale price is above fair value, the excess is treated as additional financing from the buyer-lessor. It is recorded as a financial liability separate from the lease liability, and part of each payment is treated as debt service.

The adjustment can also change the lease classification. PwC's leases guide notes that it could cause a lease that would otherwise be operating to be classified as a finance lease, which would preclude sale accounting altogether. Crowe adds that prepaid rent from a below-market price is included in the present value of the lease payments when the 90 percent test is run. A leaseback with rent set well above market in exchange for a higher price is therefore an accounting question as well as a business one, and the subject of our guide to the above-market rent trap.

If the transfer does not qualify: a failed sale

When the transfer is not a sale, the transaction is accounted for as a financing. The seller-lessee does not derecognize the building, continues to depreciate it, recognizes no gain, and records the cash received as a financial liability. Payments to the buyer-lessor are split between interest and principal, generally at the seller-lessee's incremental borrowing rate, adjusted if needed so that the liability does not grow and no loss is built in for the date control finally transfers.

The conclusion is not necessarily permanent. It is reassessed when facts change. For example, if a repurchase option that blocked sale accounting later expires unexercised, the company would recognize the sale at that point and begin accounting for the leaseback as a lease, as in the example above.

Failed-sale accounting is not a penalty and the cash is the same either way, but the financial statements look quite different, and that difference can matter to lenders and buyers of the business. We cover that in a separate guide on the balance sheet and loan covenants.

How ASC 842 compares with IFRS 16

Companies with a parent, investor or lender that reports under IFRS Accounting Standards often ask how the two frameworks differ. Both start by asking whether a sale occurred under their largely converged revenue standards, but they part ways after that.

Seller-lessee accounting: US GAAP vs IFRS 16
QuestionUS GAAP (ASC 842)IFRS 16
Is there a sale?Tested under ASC 606: a contract and a transfer of controlTested under IFRS 15: a contract and a transfer of control
Finance leasebackA finance lease for the seller-lessee, or a sales-type lease for the buyer-lessor, automatically rules out a saleClassification as a finance lease by the buyer-lessor rules out a sale, except in rare circumstances
Seller repurchase optionRules out a sale unless the price is fair value at exercise and substantially identical assets are readily available, which real estate does not meetA substantive repurchase option rules out a sale, with no fair value exception
Gain on a saleThe full difference between proceeds and carrying amountOnly the part that relates to the rights transferred to the buyer-lessor
Right-of-use assetMeasured as for any other lease; it can be zeroThe share of the previous carrying amount that relates to the right of use retained
Variable paymentsPayments based on performance or usage stay out of the lease liabilityEstimated variable payments are included, so a lease liability is always recognized
Failed saleA financing, reassessed when relevant facts changeA financial liability under IFRS 9, also reassessed when facts change

Source: KPMG, Sale and leaseback: IFRS Accounting Standards vs US GAAP (2023). A summary only; your auditors apply the standards to your facts.

Questions to settle with your CPA before the LOI

  • Would the proposed leaseback be an operating lease or a finance lease, counting the renewal options we are reasonably certain to exercise?
  • Is the proposed term a major part of the building's remaining economic life?
  • Does the present value of the rent approach the building's fair value?
  • What discount rate will we use for classification and to measure the lease liability, and does the choice change the answer?
  • Does the deal include any repurchase option, and if so, are we prepared for financing treatment?
  • Are we giving any residual value guarantee or similar support?
  • Is the sale price at fair value, and is the rent at market? What evidence supports that?
  • What gain or loss will we report, and in which period?
  • How will the new lease liability be treated under our loan covenants?

We are real estate advisors, not accountants. What we bring to this conversation is the market evidence for price and rent and the ability to negotiate term, options and repair obligations with the accounting result in view, working alongside your CPA. That is the core of our sale-leaseback service, and our guide to comparing sale-leaseback offers shows how to line up terms that affect the accounting.

Frequently asked questions

Does a sale-leaseback remove the lease obligation from the balance sheet?

No. Under ASC 842 the seller-lessee records a right-of-use asset and a lease liability for the leaseback. The owned building and any mortgage you repay come off, and the lease goes on.

Is the gain recognized immediately?

If the transfer qualifies as a sale, US GAAP has the seller-lessee recognize the gain or loss in full at the sale date, adjusted for any off-market terms. If it does not qualify, no gain is recognized until a sale is later recognized, for example when a repurchase option expires.

Does a repurchase option always prevent sale accounting?

For real estate it generally does. The exception requires a fair value exercise price and substantially identical assets readily available in the market, and real estate is treated as unique.

What is ASC 842-40?

It is the sale and leaseback subtopic of the FASB's lease standard. It decides whether the transfer is a sale by reference to ASC 606, rules out a sale when the leaseback is a finance lease or the seller holds a repurchase option, adjusts for off-market terms, and sets out how a failed sale is accounted for as a financing.

Do all companies have to adopt ASC 842?

Every entity that reports under US GAAP applies it, public or private. After a one-year delay, it took effect for private companies and private not-for-profits for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2021. If your statements are prepared on another basis, ask your CPA which rules apply.

How is lease expense recorded after a sale-leaseback?

For an operating leaseback, the seller-lessee records a single lease cost on a straight-line basis over the term while the lease liability is reduced using the effective interest method. In a failed sale there is no lease expense: the company records depreciation on the building and interest on the financial liability instead.

Sources

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Have your attorney and CPA review any sale-leaseback before you commit to it.

Want a second opinion on a sale-leaseback?

Tell us about your building and what you want the capital for. We’ll walk you through the options.

CallContact Us