By Tenant Advisory Group · Updated
Reviewed by Bill Himmelstein, CNE, Founder, CEO & Managing Broker · Illinois Managing Broker License #471003992 · 26 years in commercial real estate · Last reviewed
Short answer
Usually a sale. Under US GAAP it is a sale only if the buyer obtains control of the building. If the leaseback is a finance lease or the seller keeps a repurchase option, it is a failed sale: the building stays on the seller's books and the cash is booked as a liability, like a loan. Federal tax law applies its own ownership test.
Form and substance are tested separately
A sale-leaseback is documented as a deed and a lease. Whether it is reported that way is a different question, and it is asked twice: once by the accounting standards for your financial statements, and once by the tax law for your return. The two tests use different criteria, so a transaction can pass one and not the other. Neither conclusion is ours to give. This guide describes the risk factors so that you can raise them with your CPA, auditors and tax counsel while the terms are still open.
Financing treatment is not a legal defect and it does not undo the deal. The buyer still owns the building of record and you still pay under the lease. What changes is how the transaction appears in your financial statements and, on the tax side, which deductions each party is entitled to.
Loan or sale? The two outcomes side by side
The quickest way to see what is at stake is to put the two results next to each other. The cash you receive and the rent you pay are the same either way. What differs is what your financial statements show afterward.
| Item | Treated as a sale | Treated as a financing (failed sale) |
|---|---|---|
| The building | Removed from the balance sheet | Stays on the balance sheet and continues to be depreciated |
| Cash from the buyer | Sale proceeds | A financial liability, much like a loan |
| Gain or loss | Recognized at the sale date, adjusted for any off-market terms | None at the transfer |
| The leaseback | A right-of-use asset and a lease liability | No lease is recorded; each payment is split between interest and reduction of the liability |
| Expense pattern | Straight-line lease cost for an operating leaseback | Depreciation on the building plus interest on the liability |
| Can the answer change? | Ordinary lease accounting applies from the sale date | Yes. If the feature that blocked the sale goes away, such as a repurchase option expiring unexercised, the sale is recognized at that point |
Sources: PwC Viewpoint leases guide, sections 6.3 and 6.5; KPMG, Sale and leaseback: IFRS Accounting Standards vs US GAAP (2023). Your management and auditors reach the conclusion for your company.
For a step-by-step walk through the numbers, including journal entries for both outcomes on one hypothetical building, see our guide to sale-leaseback accounting under ASC 842.
The accounting test: a failed sale under ASC 842
Under ASC 842-40, a seller-lessee accounts for a sale only if the transfer meets the revenue standard's requirements: a contract must exist under ASC 606-10-25-1, and the buyer-lessor must obtain control of the asset under ASC 606-10-25-30. PwC's leases guide lists the indicators of control the standard points to: the seller has a present right to payment, and the buyer has legal title, physical possession, the significant risks and rewards of ownership, and has accepted the asset. They are indicators, not a checklist, and they are weighed together.
Even when those indicators point to a sale, accounting guides identify the features that most often prevent sale accounting:
- The leaseback is a finance lease. If the leaseback would be classified as a finance lease by the seller-lessee, or a sales-type lease by the buyer-lessor, control is not considered to have transferred. A lease is a finance lease when it transfers ownership, includes a purchase option the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise, runs for a major part of the asset's remaining economic life, has payments whose present value amounts to substantially all of the asset's fair value, or covers an asset so specialized the lessor has no alternative use for it.
- Renewal options that are reasonably certain to be exercised. They are included in the lease term and can push a lease into finance classification.
- A seller repurchase option. It precludes sale accounting unless the exercise price is fair value at the time of exercise and substantially identical assets are readily available in the marketplace. Real estate is treated as unique, so the exception is generally not available for a building.
- A residual value guarantee by the seller-lessee. Its present value is added to the lease payments, which can push the lease over the fair value test and into finance classification.
- Off-market pricing. Adjusting a deal to fair value can cause a lease that would otherwise be operating to be classified as a finance lease.
The present value test is where the "90 percent rule" you may hear about comes from. ASC 842 sets no bright line, but Crowe notes that "substantially all" of fair value is commonly interpreted as 90 percent or more. Because the test turns on a present value, the discount rate matters too. Crowe points out that private companies using the risk-free rate practical expedient get a lower rate than an incremental borrowing rate, which makes the threshold easier to reach.
Highly specialized buildings and very long leases deserve a careful look for the same reason. A purpose-built facility leased back for most of its remaining life can meet the finance lease criteria without any option in the deal at all.
What failed-sale accounting looks like
If the transfer is not a sale, the seller-lessee's books look as though it borrowed against the building.
- The building is not derecognized. It stays on the balance sheet and the company continues to depreciate it.
- The cash received is recorded as a financial liability.
- No gain or loss is recognized on the transfer.
- Payments to the buyer-lessor are split between interest expense and reduction of the liability.
The interest rate is not simply whatever falls out of the payments. PwC's leases guide explains that the seller-lessee generally uses its incremental borrowing rate, then adjusts it where ASC 842-40-30-6 requires: the liability may not grow over time because interest exceeds the payments, and the building's carrying amount may not exceed the liability on the date control finally passes to the buyer, which would otherwise build in a loss.
The assessment is revisited when facts change. If a repurchase option that prevented sale accounting expires unexercised, the company recognizes the sale at that point, removes the asset and the financial liability, records the difference as a gain or loss, and begins to account for the leaseback as a lease.
Why it matters commercially: the Equipment Leasing and Finance Association observes that finance obligations are typically included in leverage calculations while operating lease obligations typically are not, so a failed sale can affect debt covenants. If part of your purpose is to reduce borrowed money as your lenders measure it, a failed sale may not deliver that. We cover the lender side in how a sale-leaseback affects your balance sheet and covenants.
Sale-leaseback vs traditional financing: where the line blurs
Owners often weigh a sale-leaseback against a mortgage or a bank loan, and the comparison is a fair one. Both turn the building into cash and both create a fixed payment. The business differences, who keeps the building and its future value, how long the payment runs and what restrictions come with the money, are covered in sale-leaseback vs refinancing your mortgage and sale-leaseback vs a bank loan or line of credit.
The point for this guide is narrower. The more a deal's terms resemble a loan, the more likely the accounting rules or the IRS will treat it as one. These are the loan-like features that come up in the sources above:
- A right to buy the building back, especially at a fixed or formula price rather than fair market value at the time.
- A lease that, with renewals you are reasonably certain to exercise, covers most of the building's remaining life.
- Rent whose present value approaches the full price, so the investor recovers its money as a lender would.
- A guarantee of the building's value at the end of the lease, which leaves ownership risk with you.
- A price and rent that are not at market, so part of the cash is really borrowed from the buyer.
None of these is improper. Each one simply moves the deal toward the financing side of the line, and you should know which side you will land on before you sign.
The tax test: is the buyer really the owner?
How a respected sale-leaseback is taxed, including gain on the sale and the deduction for rent, is covered in how a sale-leaseback is taxed. This section covers the earlier question: whether the transaction is respected as a sale and a lease at all.
Federal tax law asks who owns the property in substance. The leading case is Frank Lyon Co. v. United States, decided by the Supreme Court in 1978. A bank arranged for an outside company to take title to its new headquarters and lease it back, with rent matched to the mortgage payments and options for the bank to repurchase at set prices. The IRS treated the arrangement as a financing and denied the buyer's depreciation and interest deductions.
The Court sided with the taxpayer. It held that where there is a genuine multiple-party transaction with economic substance, compelled or encouraged by business or regulatory realities, the government should honor the allocation of rights and duties the parties made, so long as the lessor retains significant and genuine attributes of traditional lessor status. Among the facts the Court pointed to: the buyer alone was liable on the mortgage, the rents and option prices were reasonable and negotiated at arm's length, the buyer bore real risk, and there was no understanding that the bank would exercise its options.
A Journal of Accountancy article on sale-leasebacks of real property lists practical tests drawn from this line of authority. It stresses that no single factor controls and that the overall facts and circumstances decide the question.
- The buyer must have taken an equity interest in the property and assumed the risk of loss.
- The useful life of the property must exceed the lease term, so that the buyer owns something of value when the lease ends.
- Any repurchase by the seller must be at fair market value, not at a discount.
- Renewal rent must be set at a fair rental value.
- The buyer should reasonably expect a profit from the price and the rent over the lease term.
Since 2010 the Internal Revenue Code has also spelled out the economic substance doctrine. Where the doctrine is relevant, section 7701(o) treats a transaction as having economic substance only if it changes the taxpayer's economic position in a meaningful way apart from federal income tax effects, and the taxpayer has a substantial purpose for entering into it apart from those effects. The business reasons for your deal, such as what the proceeds will fund, are worth documenting at the time.
The stakes for the seller sit in the rent deduction. The Internal Revenue Code allows a business deduction for rent paid on property to which the taxpayer has not taken or is not taking title, or in which it has no equity. A seller who keeps what amounts to an ownership stake, for example through a bargain repurchase right, raises the question of whether its payments are rent at all. How a recharacterized deal would be taxed in your case is a question for your tax advisor.
Risk factors to check in your own term sheet
- Does the seller have any option to repurchase, and is the price fixed, formula-based or fair market value at exercise?
- Is there any understanding, written or not, that the seller will buy the building back?
- Counting renewals we are reasonably certain to exercise, how does the lease term compare with the building's remaining economic life?
- Does the present value of the rent approach the building's fair value?
- If we are a private company, which discount rate will we use for lease classification, and does it change the answer?
- Is the building so specialized that the buyer would have no alternative use for it?
- Is the sale price at fair value and the rent at market, with evidence to support both?
- Are renewal rents set at fair rental value?
- Is the seller guaranteeing the building's residual value or otherwise protecting the buyer from ownership risk?
- Are buyer and seller related parties?
- Have the auditors and tax counsel seen the term sheet, not only the final documents?
Most of these features are requested for sound business reasons: an owner wants a path back to ownership, or a longer term for a better price. The point is not to avoid them at all costs but to know the reporting result before agreeing to them.
Where the real estate negotiation fits
Several of the risk factors come down to market evidence: what the building is worth, what market rent is, and whether a renewal rent or an option price is fair. Those are real estate questions. We represent the seller and future tenant, so our contribution is to document price and rent against the market and to negotiate term, renewals and any purchase rights in coordination with your CPA and counsel, so the structure you sign is the one you intended to report.
If a buyback right matters to you, read can you buy your building back later? before the letter of intent, and see the above-market rent trap if an offer leans on higher rent to reach its price. Our sale-leaseback advisory service covers both the sale and the lease you will live with.
Frequently asked questions
Is a failed sale a bad outcome?
Not necessarily. The cash and the lease are the same. The difference is in reporting: the building and a financial liability stay on your books and no gain is recognized. Whether that is acceptable depends on your lenders, investors and goals.
Can a deal be a sale for accounting and a loan for tax, or the reverse?
The accounting standards and the tax law apply different tests, so the answers can differ. Ask your CPA to analyze both from the same term sheet.
Does any repurchase option turn the deal into a financing?
For accounting, a repurchase option on real estate generally prevents sale treatment. For tax, a repurchase right at fair market value is viewed differently from one at a bargain price, and no single factor controls.
What is the 90% rule in leasing?
It is shorthand for one of the finance lease tests: whether the present value of the lease payments, plus any residual value the lessee guarantees, amounts to substantially all of the asset's fair value. ASC 842 sets no bright line, but practice commonly reads substantially all as 90 percent or more. In a sale-leaseback, a finance leaseback means a failed sale.
What is an example of a failed sale-leaseback?
A company sells its building and leases it back with an option to buy it back for a fixed price after five years. Because the option is a repurchase right on real estate, the buyer does not obtain control. The company keeps the building on its books and records the cash as a financial liability until the option expires or is exercised.
Who decides how the transaction is treated?
Your company's management and auditors decide the accounting treatment under ASC 842. The tax treatment is reported on your return and can be examined by the IRS.
Sources
- PwC Viewpoint, Leases guide: 6.3 Sale and leaseback, determining whether a sale has occurred
- PwC Viewpoint, Leases guide: 6.4 When the transaction is not at fair value
- PwC Viewpoint, Leases guide: 6.5 Failed sale and leaseback transaction
- KPMG: Sale and leaseback, IFRS Accounting Standards vs US GAAP
- Crowe: Accounting treatment for sale and leaseback transactions
- Equipment Leasing and Finance Association: The New Sale and Leaseback Model
- The Bonadio Group: How to Avoid a Failed Sale and Leaseback
- Journal of Accountancy: Accounting for sale and leaseback transactions
- GAAP Dynamics: Accounting for sale and leaseback transactions under ASC 842
- FinQuery: Sale-leaseback transactions and accounting under ASC 842 explained
- Cornell Legal Information Institute: Frank Lyon Co. v. United States, 435 U.S. 561 (1978)
- Journal of Accountancy: Sale and Leaseback of Real Property
- Cornell Legal Information Institute: 26 U.S. Code § 7701(o), economic substance doctrine
- Cornell Legal Information Institute: 26 U.S. Code § 162, Trade or business expenses
This guide is general information, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Have your attorney and CPA review any sale-leaseback before you commit to it.

